Chaco Canyon Consulting

The Race to the South Pole: Lessons in Risk Management for Leaders


On 14 December 1911, four men led by Roald Amundsen reached the South Pole. Thirty-five days later, Robert F. Scott and four others followed. Amundsen had won the race to the pole. Amundsen's party returned to base on 26 January 1912. Scott's party perished. As historical drama, why this happened is interesting enough, but to organizational leaders, the story is fascinating as a source of lessons in risk management.


Most of our learning about leadership and management comes from personal experience, from the experiences of others, from texts and professional materials and from presentations and training. The content of these sources is specifically about leadership and management. This is what I call direct learning.

The Race to the South Pole: Lessons in Risk Management for Leaders
The Race to the South Pole: Lessons in Risk Management for Leaders

But there are other ways to learn about leadership or management, ways I call indirect. One slightly surprising source is film. Many films aren't directly about leadership or management, and yet, indirectly, they have much to teach us. One of these is The Last Place on Earth. There are many more, of course.

I mention The Last Place on Earth because it's the story of the race to the South Pole, which occurred in the Antarctic summer of 1911-1912. The film is based on the book of the same title, by Roland Huntford. I recommend both.

In this program, we use the history of this event to explore important lessons about managing risk in organizational efforts of all kinds, including planned and unplanned change, complex projects, and mergers and acquisitions. We'll see why leaders are uniquely positioned to manage whatever risks can be anticipated, and many risks we can't anticipate.

The leaders of these two expeditions took very different approaches to risk management. By comparing their approaches, we can come to understand the differences in the outcomes of the two expeditions. We'll explore a leadership-based approach to risk analysis and planning that considers the interplay between three categories of risk sources: the individual, the organizational, and the environmental. This framework is especially well suited to large, complex, high-risk organizational efforts.

Attendees learn valuable lessons from history that they can apply immediately to managing current organizational efforts and planning new ones. The drama of the story of Amundsen and Scott makes these lessons more intriguing, easier to learn, and much, much more memorable.

Course structure and content

Each of the lessons we examine is illustrated with background and stories from one or both of the two expeditions. The stories are memorable, and told with an emphasis on their value to leaders and managers of modern organizations.

Here is a description of the framework we use for analyzing the risks these expeditions faced:

The individual
These expeditions relied for success on covering all their needs for almost two years with the resources they had landed on the continent. The loss of any one person, or the failures, flaws, and shortcomings of any single person could have had — and did have — significant impact on expedition success. The two expeditions approach individual-centered risk management very differently, leading to very different outcomes.
In modern organizations, we aren't as isolated as these expeditions were in Antarctica. But the consequences of turnover, or of individual failures, flaws, and shortcomings can be just as severe, because of the requirement that we work within tight constraints on resources and schedule. Replacing anyone is possible, but the impact on organizational efforts is often unacceptably severe.
The organization
Risk sources within the organization include the effects of management decisions, of course. But beyond that are the sometimes-unpredictable interactions between any or all of a long list of organizational components: people, groups, teams, technologies, processes, structures, politics, equipment of all kinds, information, beliefs, and procedures. The stories of the two expeditions provide many examples of how these interactions produce risks that affected expedition success.
In modern organizations, when we are actually aware of organizational risk, we can sometimes manage it. Too often, though, we fail to perceive in our own organizations what is obvious to an outsider. Examining the management of organizational risk in these two historical examples helps leaders understand how difficult organizational risk management can be.
The environment
The environment external to the organization has a variety of risk effects. Certainly it's a source of risk, but it also supplies resources. Most important, it is dynamic. Its changes are perhaps its most troublesome attributes. Both expeditions dealt with weather, and both dealt with the constraints imposed by the environment, albeit in different ways. The two expeditions provide a marvelous comparison that illustrates the advantages of finding ways to exploit the environment to manage all three categories of risk sources.
In modern organizations, we tend to overuse strategies that "fight" the external environment. Approaches that exploit the attributes of the environment to manage risk more cleverly are usually cheaper and much more effective.

This program is most suitable for keynote presentations and conference general sessions, or for large groups. Heavily illustrated with maps and original photographs, the stories bring the events of 1908 through 1912 — almost 100 years ago — to life. It's especially suitable for audiences that desire some relief from the sometimes-dry style of presentations that address similar subject matter. Audience interaction and table discussions about accompanying prepared discussion questions bring the lessons of the Race to the Pole into focus in contemporary experience.

Program outline

  1. Introduction
    1. Amundsen and Scott: Background
    2. Antarctica as it was known in 1910
    3. The two expeditions compared
  2. Three categories of risk sources, with examples
    1. Individual
    2. Organizational
    3. Environmental
  3. Risk management risk
    1. Definition
    2. Sources of risk management risk, with examples
    3. Comparing the two expeditions
    4. Mitigation strategies
  4. Summary and wrap-up
    1. How we can apply these lessons in modern projects
    2. What to do tomorrow
    3. Monitoring your own learning
    4. Resources for the future

Learning model

We usually think of project management skills as rather technical — free of emotional content. We hold this belief even though we know that our most difficult situations can be highly charged. Despite our most sincere beliefs, taking a project organization to the next level of performance does require learning to apply knowledge management skills even in situations of high emotional content. That's why this workshop uses a learning model that differs from the one often used for technical content.

Our learning model is partly experiential, which makes the material accessible even during moments of stress. Using a mix of presentation, simulation, group discussion, and metaphorical team problems, we make available to participants the resources they need to make new, more constructive choices even in tense situations.

Target audience

Project managers, program managers, managers, executives, and leaders at all levels. Participants should have experienced at least six months working with or as a member of a team.

Program duration

Available formats range from 50 minutes to one full day. The longer formats allow for more coverage or more material, more experiential content and deeper understanding of issues specific to audience experience.

Currently scheduled public events

At this time, there are no public events scheduled for this program. But if you would like to observe the program, I might be able to arrange an opportunity with a current client. Contact Rick for details.

Rick BrennerWhether you're a decision maker or someone about whom other people make decisions — or both! — the right coach can make a difference in your life. I might be the right coach for you. Call me, Rick Brenner, at (866) 378-5470 for a no-cost informal chat. Sign up in November and receive two hours as a bonus. Check it out!
What People Say About Rick's Programs
  • "Rick is a dynamic presenter who thinks on his feet to keep the material relevant to the group."
    — Tina L. Lawson, Technical Project Manager, BankOne.
  • "Rick truly has his finger on the pulse of teams and their communication."
    — Mark Middleton, Team Lead, SERS
Ebooks, booklets and tip books on project management, conflict, writing email, effective meetings and more.
Comprehensive collection of all e-books and e-bookletsSave a bundle and even more important save time! Order the Combo Package and download all ebooks and tips books at once.
My free weekly email newsletter gives concrete tips and suggestions for dealing with the challenging but everyday situations we all face.
A Tip A DayA Tip a Day arrives by email, or by RSS Feed, each business day. It's 20 to 30 words at most, and gives you a new perspective on the hassles and rewards of work life. Most tips also contain links to related articles. Free!
If your teams don't yet consistently achieve state-of-the-art teamwork, check out this catalog. Help is just a few clicks away!
Ebooks, booklets and tip books on project management, conflict, writing email, effective meetings and more.
SSL